Skip to main content

States and Courts Counterbalance Trump

From the series Chronicles of the new American nationalism

Donald Trump’s political agenda has been dictated by the tempo of the dozens of executive orders, memoranda, and proclamations he has signed, challenging international partners abroad, and Congress, the States of the Union, and the bureaucracy at home. The execution of some orders has already been temporarily suspended by federal judges, while the chaos caused by a memorandum led the administration itself to withdraw it. Other rulings are expected from the courts at the request of citizens, NGOs, and States.

Furthermore, as James Politi of the Financial Times notes, “the result of his political success” in the elections is that Trump will have to satisfy “a much more diverse political coalition” than in his first term. Ross Douthat, a conservative commentator for The New York Times, also believes that “at least until the Democratic Party gets up off the mat, this means the most important conflicts in American politics are happening within the court of Trump”.

Conflicting Factions

An “obvious” conflict for Douthat is the one between MAGA (Make America Great Again) “populism” and “Silicon Valley libertarianism”. Elon Musk said he is ready for “war” to defend the visas with which many companies import skilled workers. Steve Bannon, one of Trump’s main strategists during his first term, has pledged to “take down” Musk and the “broligarchs” of the PayPal Mafia, who do not defend the “Nation-State”.

Additionally, according to Douthat, a clash over foreign policy could arise in the executive. Secretary of State Marco Rubio and National Security Advisor Mike Waltz are considered to be “hawks” on the Middle East. The Pentagon top brass, however, includes Michael DiMino, a CIA analyst who is cautious towards Tehran, and Elbridge Colby, head of policy planning and author of the first Trump presidency’s National Defense Strategy. Colby considers China to be the main threat and the Middle East a secondary theatre and he does not want the US to be distracted by a war there.

However, there are “a few more internal wars to watch”, continues Douthat. Trump’s “court” is full of financiers from the “elite”, such as Scott Bessent at the Treasury and Howard Lutnick at Commerce, for the likes of whom Wall Street should not be disturbed by an excess of protectionism.

According to the Financial Times, Bessent had prepared a gradual monthly increase in tariffs of 2.5%, to give companies time to adapt and offer partners the opportunity to negotiate. But Trump, with emergency powers, imposed a sharp increase in levies on goods from China (10%) and from Mexico and Canada (25%).

The reaction of the markets and partners constituted a natural counterweight, provoking a reaction from the members of the administration. Peter Navarro, senior advisor to the White House and a strong supporter of tariffs, emerged as a “key figure” working with Trade Representative (USTR) Jamieson Greer. Lutnick, playing a “starring role”, apparently met with Canadian and Mexican officials even before the tariffs were imposed. When the tariffs were suspended by Trump, Navarro praised both Lutnick and Bessent, pointing to the “immediate results” obtained in the negotiations.

Challenges from the States

Rana Foroohar, a commentator at the Financial Times, writes: “As fast as the new president can sign executive orders, individual state governments are stepping up to challenge them in court. The upshot will be a more confusing environment for business and a richer one for lawyers”. The States governed by the Democrats “look for ways to shield themselves” from the incursions with which the federal power would like to change their regulations on immigration, production, and “monopoly power”, or make “massive cuts” to subsidies for businesses, health, and emergency services.

Moreover, Foroohar notes, the Democrats govern some of the States with the highest levels of consumption. California, Illinois, Massachusetts and New York “can create strong demand signals for the rest of the country” in favour of certain production standards, which companies adapt to despite the costs, “even if the president doesn’t like it”.

Opposition in the Senate

Former Republican leader Mitch McConnell has retired, but his term has not expired. He outlined a foreign policy strategy with an essay in Foreign Affairs and opposed some of Trump’s nominations. The GOP holds a slim majority (53-47) and the shift of a handful of them can make all the difference.

Matt Gaetz, Trump’s choice for the Justice Department, avoided Senate scrutiny by withdrawing his nomination. Deeming Peter Hegseth unsuitable as head of the Pentagon, McConnell voted against his nomination, together with Lisa Murkowski (Alaska) and Susan Collins (Maine), forcing Vice-President J. D. Vance to cast a tie-breaking vote. Finally, McConnell, a man who survived polio in the years before the vaccine, was the only GOP senator to vote against Robert F. Kennedy Jr., the vaccine sceptic who has become Secretary of Health and Human Services.

Chuck Schumer, leader of the Democratic senators, urged by six governors, some of them of national fame such as Tim Walz (Minnesota), asked Trump to withdraw the nomination of Russ Vought as head of the Office of Management and Budget (OMB).

Vought believes that the 1974 Impoundment Control Act, which reaffirmed the power of Congress over public spending, is “unconstitutional”. He supports the idea that the executive branch has the power to seize funds approved by Congress and to reform the so-called administrative state. “We want the bureaucrats to be traumatically affected”, he said in 2024, and that “when they wake up in the morning, we want them to not want to go to work”. In an essay for Project 2025 of the Heritage Foundation, he called for a president with the “boldness to bend or break the bureaucracy” and the “self-denial to [...] send power away from Washington” and “back to America’s families, faith communities, local governments, and States”.

Bureaucratic-media tangle

Through the president’s executive orders and the actions of the Department of Government Efficiency led by Musk in liaison with the OMB, the administration is attacking the prerogatives of departments and their officials, even at senior levels. An executive order has frozen the funding of USAID, the foreign development agency, whose goal, writes the Wall Street Journal, is “to make friends and influence countries in the American interest”, through funding and NGOs.

The attack on USAID has been toned down by Marco Rubio, the head of the State Department on which the agency depends. Moreover, USAID was founded by an act of Congress, and in the controversy one of the claims is that it would be unconstitutional to dissolve it and to cut its programmes, which are mostly financed by other acts of Congress. The WSJ “wouldn’t mind” if USAID “vanished” but warns that the “uproar” around the operation “is a taste of the pushback that Messrs. Musk and Trump are going to face as they work to shrink and reform the executive branch”. The conservative newspaper predicts a revolt of the departments, hand in hand with the opposition newspapers.

Lotta Comunista, February 2025

Labels:

Popular posts from this blog

The Works of Marx and Engels and the Bolshevik Model

Internationalism Pages 12–13 In the autumn of 1895 Lenin commented on the death of Friedrich Engels: "After his friend Karl Marx (who died in 1883), Engels was the finest scholar and teacher of the modern proletariat in the whole civilised world. […] In their scientific works, Marx and Engels were the first to explain that socialism is not the invention of dreamers, but the final aim and necessary result of the development of the productive forces in modern society. All recorded history hitherto has been a history of class struggle, of the succession of the rule and victory of certain social classes over others. And this will continue until the foundations of class struggle and of class domination – private property and anarchic social production – disappear. The interests of the proletariat demand the destruction of these foundations, and therefore the conscious class struggle of the organised workers must be directed against them. And every class strugg...
Read more

In the Depth of Our Class

The pandemic of the century is a storm that does not subside; it returns to its rampage after 40 million infections and more than a million official victims, perhaps two million according to estimates on the excess deaths. In the contention between powers, China stands as the winner: it seems to have tamed the virus, and industry and services are up and running; the USA and Europe, on the other hand, are moving towards a new wave of infections that casts yet more shadows on the economic cycle. Political structures and health systems are at the height of tension. In America, the elections have judged Donald Trump’s rash demagogy on the basis of the opposite reasons for containing the pandemic and the intolerance of small and large producers; in Europe the executives are attempting to steer between the surge in infections, increasingly stringent confinement measures and the threats of fiscal jacquerie in the tourism and catering sectors. Almost everywhere, in the Old Continent, governm...
Read more

The Unstoppable Force: Capital’s Demand for Migrant Labour

Internationalism No. 78-79, August-September 2025 Page 16 “Before Giorgia Meloni became Italy’s prime minister, she pledged to cut immigration. Since she has been in government the number of non-EU work visas issued by Italy has increased”. This is how The Economist of April 26th summarises the schizophrenia of their politics; and this is not only true in Italy: “Net migration also surged in post-Brexit Britain”. The needs of the economic system do not coincide with the rhetoric of parliamentarism. And vice versa. Schizophrenia and imbalances in their politics Returning to Italy, the Bank of Italy has pointed out that by 2040, in just fifteen years, there will be a shortage of five million people of working age, which could lead to an estimated 11% contraction in GDP. This is why even Italy’s “sovereignist” government is preparing to widen the net of its Immigration Flow Decree. The latest update, approved on June 30th, provides for the entry of almost ...
Read more

Democratic Defeat in the Urban Vote

Internationalism No. 71, January 2025 Page 2 From the series Elections in the USA A careful analysis of the 2022 mid-term elections revealed the symptoms of a Democratic Party malaise which subsequently fully manifested itself in the latest presidential election, with the heavy loss of support in its traditional strongholds of the metropolitan areas of New York City and Chicago, and the State of California. A defeat foretold Republican votes rose from 51 million in the previous 2018 midterms to 54 million in 2022, a gain of 3 million. The Democrat vote fell from 61 to 51 million, a loss of 10 million. The Republicans gained only three votes for every ten lost by the Democrats, while the other seven became abstentions. In 2022, we analysed the elections in New York City by borough, the governmental districts whose names are well known through movies and TV series. In The Bronx, where the average yearly household income is $35,000, the Democrats lost 52,00...
Read more

The Comprehensive Agreement on Investment Strengthens the ‘European Party’ in China

From the series News from the Silk Road “Chinese people treat [US democracy] as a variety show which is much more interesting than House of Cards’ [...]”. Beijing does not feel the same embarrassment as the old democracies of the West faced with the grotesque scenes of demonstration against the Capitol organised by the president of the United States. Zhao Minghao from the Chongyang Institute spelled out the obvious in his analysis some time earlier: “the political farce by the incumbent president and some Republican lawmakers is reflecting the profound crisis on US domestic politics.” The Global Times is serving a hefty bill to the ideologies of liberal interventionism: “the ‘beacon of democracy’, and the beautiful rhetoric of ‘City upon a Hill’ [...]” are undergoing a serious debacle or in other words, a “Waterloo of US international image”. It will be a while before the US can “interfere in other countries’ domestic affairs with the excuse of ‘democracy’[...]”. Attention is also...
Read more

‘Two Hands’ and ‘Two Roads’

From the series News from the Silk Road The international tensions which China will face on the seas in the next fifteen years could find a buffer in the expansion of China’s influence on land in Central, Southern and Western Asia. Wang Jisi is the dean of the School of International Studies at the University of Beijing and a major figure of the American party in China. His unexpected foray into ‘geopolitics’ has reignited the old clash between different American currents — a phenomenon we analysed more than twenty years ago. At the time, Robert Manning, the author of The Asian Energy Factor and adviser to the State Department in 1991, viewed Asia’s growing dependence on the Persian Gulf for its energy requirements in the light of geoeconomics and geostrategy and foresaw a possible convergence between the USA and China. From a geoeconomic standpoint, both trade and the funding and development of the infrastructure necessary for Asia’s energy needs were more important than terri...
Read more

Uneven Development, Job Cuts, and the Crisis of Labour Under Global Capitalism

Internationalism No. 73, March 2025 Page 16 Uneven development is a fundamental law of capitalism. We have a macroscopic expression of this in the changing balance of power between States: Atlantic decline and Asian rise are the key dynamics behind the political processes of this era, including wars caused by the crisis in the world order. But behind all this there is a differentiated economic trend, starting from companies and sectors: hence the differentiated conditions for wage earners. And this is the element to keep in mind for an effective defensive struggle. It’s only the beginning The electrical and digital restructuring imposed by global market competition affects various production sectors. The car industry is the most obvious, due to the familiarity of the companies and brands involved. We have already reported on the agreement reached before Christmas at Volkswagen, which can be summarised as a reduction of 35,000 employees by 2030. Die Zeit [De...
Read more

Chinese Rearmament Projects Itself in Asia

Internationalism No. 78-79, August-September 2025 Page 5 From the series Asian giants Trends in rearmament spending and comparisons of military equipment are increasingly set to dominate coverage of the contention between powers in the crisis in the world order . The military factor has entered the strategic debate, accompanied by a wealth of figures and technical details. The increase in military spending as a percentage of GDP represents a widespread sign of the rearmament cycle at this juncture, but spending alone cannot entirely explain the situation, given the qualitatively different natures of the arsenals being compared. Nor are comparisons between this or that type of weapon useful in themselves, because ultimately all weapons are only ever used in combination with the complex military means available to a power, either in alliance or in conflict with other powers in the system of States. Therefore, while it is difficult to assess the real significa...
Read more

Armed Negotiations between the Gulf and the Mediterranean

David Petraeus, Commander of the US forces in Iraq and the Gulf in 2007-2008, then director of the CIA in 2011-12, described the elimination of Iranian General Qasem Soleimani on January 3 rd in Baghdad as a defensive action , with which the Trump presidency restored a US deterrence , which was weakened by recent Iranian actions . This is a reference to the attacks conducted indirectly, unclaimed by Tehran, against the Saudi oil infrastructures on September 14 th 2019. In March 2008, when the forces under Petraeus’ command supported the Iraqi Army in the fight against local Shite militias, Soleimani sent a message to the American general: informing him that he was the person in charge for Iranian policies in Iraq, Syria, Lebanon and Gaza therefore the channel through which to define an agreement to resolve the various issues with Tehran. Petraeus holds the advisors of the Quds Force, the spearhead of the Pasdaran asymmetric operations, responsible for the killing of around 600 ...
Read more

Indo-African Opposition at the WTO

Since March 1 st , the Nigerian economist Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala has been the new director general of the World Trade Organization. Like a coach hired by a team languishing at the bottom of its league — writes Larry Elliott of The Guardian — Okonjo finds herself in the happy position of taking over at the WTO when the only way is up , This historic international institution is unlikely to experience extinction or irrelevance. However, the appointment of Okonjo does not in itself remedy WTO’s deep troubles. An alternative in plurilateralism The negotiating function of the WTO has been lacking for twenty years now. The latest ambitious goal of liberalising trade in goods and services, announced in Doha in November 2001, became bogged down by the impossibility of a general compromise between old powers and large emerging economies. In 2015 Michael Froman, President Barack Obama’s Trade Representative (USTR), officially called for the abandonment of the Doha Round. Froman’s alternative p...
Read more