Skip to main content

The National Gamble of Poland

From the series European News

In a lawsuit brought by Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki, the Constitutional Tribunal, which is composed of judges chosen by the government, ruled that fundamental parts of the EU Treaty are incompatible with the Constitution of the Republic of Poland. This ruling thus denies the primacy of European law over national law, undermining both the political assumption of continental integration and the supranational character of the EU.

Vectors of Polish history

We can shed light on this event if we consider the four field vectors that cross Poland: its traditional ethnic-religious nationalism, its marked Atlantic tropism, the objective attraction exerted by the European force field, and the looming threat of Russia.

The general picture is global collisions: China’s irruption and the crisis in the world order have put pressure on Warsaw to define its strategic position. The process is nonlinear, and creates political and institutional convulsions with unpredictable outcomes.

The history of Poland’s relationship with Europe and its German heart is troubled. After having had royal dynasties and an independent state for centuries, Poland fell under foreign domination. Since the end of the 18th century, it has been the subject of partition between Prussia, Russia and Austria, and Polish state unity has been continually challenged, in the face of a continuity of national culture which has never been interrupted and where an important integrating role was played by the Catholic Church , according to the historian Krzysztof Pomian [L'Europe et Ses Nations, ]. Only after the First World War did Poland regain independence under Jozef Pilsudski, but in it was split again, this time between Nazi Germany and the USSR. After the Second World War, it became a Russian satellite.

This condition led the Polish bourgeoise to seek alliances elsewhere: with the Anglo-Saxon powers, which thus gained an option to interfere in Central Europe’s affairs. For London, Poland’s accession to the EU helped to weaken the Rhineland centralisation tendency, while moreover it utilised the Eurosceptic currents present in Warsaw. After being freed from the Russian yoke, Poland has been reluctant to relinquish the sovereignty that it regained to Europe.

In Eastern Europe, marked by bitter ethnic-territorial disputes, immigration and the opening of borders are the subject of the national demagogy. Global changes have brought insecurity, and the prevalent feeling is that globalisation has been a negative experience, marked by strong flows of emigration, whereas the West has seen great advantages. Coal-dependent Poland is now complaining of being penalised by Europe’s ambitious climate targets. Warsaw intends to benefit from the new cycle of state intervention, enabled by the Next Generation EU fund, but on its own national terms.

Contingent aspects, such as the composition of the acting coalition government, are also involved in this dynamic: the extreme right of United Poland (Solidarna Polska) influences the PiS (Prawo i Sprawiedliwosé — Law and Justice) and, according to some versions, has forced Jaroslaw Kaczynski to overplay his hand with Europe.

Dirty remain

The crisis has crossed the threshold of political rhetoric because it sets some powers against each other. But, by revealing the objective limits of its gamble, the Polish government resolutely ruled out the Polexit scenario. The Financial Times states that the Polish Constitutional Tribunal judgment poses a bigger challenge to the EU’s unity than Brexit, because it is a direct attack on the EU’s legal order. […] The UK withdrew from the EU; Poland is asserting its constitutional independence while staying inside. It is corroding the union’s integrity from within []. The Economist speaks of dirty remain. [].

The Polish case also involves a risk of contagion because, in the new political cycle of proprietary fears and petty-bourgeois anxieties, it is grasped by other sovereigntist parties out of political opportunism or mere electoral calculations: in France, in addition to the extreme right of Marine Le Pen and Eric Zemmour, Michel Barnier and Valérie Pécresse of Les Républicains party also winked at Warsaw. Then there are, among others, the Hungarian nationalists, the Spanish post-Francoists of Vox, the Italian post-fascist party Fratelli d’Italia and, still in Italy, la Lega [formerly Northem League] with a more nuanced position.

In the plurality of EU superstructures, the dialectic between national and supranational powers is a natural regularity. There have been other legal disputes, such as that delivering a ruling from the German Constitutional Court on the purchase of ECB securities. However, in these cases, the confrontation took place in compliance with the separation of powers, and a solution was found in the spirit of institutional loyal cooperation. In the Polish case, as former French diplomat Pierre Vimont points out, the legal rebellion is a political instrument in the hands of Poland’s executive branch, and moves directly against the principle of supranational EU integration.

The rule of law and EU funds

Sergio Fabbrini, in the Italian business daily Il Sole24 Ore, notes that the decision of the Polish court had an immediate purpose: one aiming to delegitimise the legal architecture of the Next Generation EU [NGEU] program. The latter, in fact, has established a conditionality regime according to which European funds cannot be distributed to countries that do not respect the rule of law, which is vital for the functioning of the single market. Poland is expected to benefit from as much as €36 billion from the NGEU funds and €120 billion from the Structural and Cohesion Funds. Fabbrini explains Poland’s move in this way: If the rule of law is established by the national Courts and Constitutions, then the Commission cannot prevent the payment of European funds to Poland for violations of the rule of law.

But the EU cannot allow one of its members to ignore the primacy of the Buropean Treaty. On the formal and legal level, the clash seems irreconcilable. Angela Merkel, however, faithful to her method of seeking for a political synthesis, urges a political solution, and warns against withholding European funds destined for Warsaw: We have big problems, but my advice is to solve them in talks, to find compromises [October 15th].

Poland’s National-Europeanism

In spite of national rhetoric, in fact, Berlin knows that the European constriction imposed on Warsaw is deep, even vital from an economic point of view — not only because of the dependence on EU funds, but also because of the structural integration of the Polish industrial sector with the industries of Rhineland and the rest of Europe. On the wider strategic terrain, a break with the EU would be fatal and offer no way out.

Could the strength of the European constriction plunge Poland into a constitutional crisis, until the fall of its government? In a condition of marked political imbalance, the conservative Polish newspaper Rzeczpospolita, which is pro-European and critical of PiS, evoked a parallel with Italy, hoping for the advent of a Polish Monti [i.e., a pro-Europe grand commis].

The polls show a majority in favour of the EU close to 90% (which former Prime Minister Donald Tusk seeks to unite); this majority, however, can harbour different gradations of a nationally motivated Europeanism in its midst, which opposes the principle of an ever closer union.

The Rhenish attraction

In the turbulent phase which has commenced, however, doubts about America’s engagement in Europe could push Warsaw towards the Rhine. Rzeczpospolita interprets the AUKUS affair as a warning: Biden will not spare Poland, if he deems its sacrifice necessary. In an interview with the Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, Morawiecki reiterated the sovereigntist line, but pointed out Poland’s interest in a possible European common defence, so far always opposed due to a sense of loyalty towards NATO: If the EU wants to survive, if it wants to be strong, it must remain a Europe of sovereign states, a Europe of homelands. It must have respect for their traditions and cultures, as well as a close economic cooperation. And it must have also a real European army, which can defend Europe in the south, east and north. The Bulgarian scholar Ivan Krastev, interviewed by Le Figaro, urges France to speak to countries that are serious on the military level, such as Poland, which is certainly obsessed with itself, but is attached to the notion of power.

Rzeczpospolita shows concern about the PiS nationalist gamble, in the context of the changing transatlantic relationship and the end of the Merkel era: Angela Merkel’s priority was to keep our country in the EU. This won’t be the most important thing for the next German government. An editorial is titled: Goodbye Angela, we return to the East. But the Russian bear looms on the eastern flank, while China advances on the horizon.

Warsaw in the Kantian garden

François Heisbourg writes that the European powers, after having fought for centuries, have created a Kantian garden in the EU. The Eastern States have been integrated into this intra-European peaceful ideal. […] The German-Polish reconciliation, the pacification of relations between Hungary and its Danube neighbours, the velvet divorce’ between the Czech Republic and Slovakia show how the values of non-violence have been integrated by the newcomers. However, Heisbourg points out that Europe has not marched 'at the same pace in this direction. In the future, other historical shocks may follow — such as those of the late 1940s, which opposed two different Europes, or those of the late 1980s, which united them — causing differentiated effects in different parts of Europe. Heisbourg continues: Why think that the Kantian garden is by construction sheltered from such disturbances? Now, it is precisely the series of strategic ruptures that are looming at this moment that will test Europe’s ability to preserve in a united way the integrity of the European garden. These challenges require a European response [La Fin du Réve Européen, ].

Against the ideology of a benign (because it was pacified internally) Power Europe, we have emphasised the imperialist character of the European project, which has eliminated war within its borders to project power externally, on a continental scale, as a reaction to the rise of Asia. Heisbourg observes that, while the strategic context is worsening, the Kantian character of intra-European relations is no longer an element of progression towards a more advanced integration. Pacification is a necessary but not sufficient condition for the creation of a federation.

A Europe that aims to be a power that protects not only in the economy, but also in politics and in the military field, may possibly increase the attractive force it exerts on Warsaw. The question concerns the ability of the EU to express a degree of centralisation that is sufficient for the world contention. The Kantian garden, under capitalism, is just the need for unity of European imperialism. But the world is Hobbesian.

— Dalvit, Federico. Azzardo nazionale polacco Lotta Comunista, , p. 5

Labels:

Popular posts from this blog

Chinese Rearmament Projects Itself in Asia

Internationalism No. 78-79, August-September 2025 Page 5 From the series Asian giants Trends in rearmament spending and comparisons of military equipment are increasingly set to dominate coverage of the contention between powers in the crisis in the world order . The military factor has entered the strategic debate, accompanied by a wealth of figures and technical details. The increase in military spending as a percentage of GDP represents a widespread sign of the rearmament cycle at this juncture, but spending alone cannot entirely explain the situation, given the qualitatively different natures of the arsenals being compared. Nor are comparisons between this or that type of weapon useful in themselves, because ultimately all weapons are only ever used in combination with the complex military means available to a power, either in alliance or in conflict with other powers in the system of States. Therefore, while it is difficult to assess the real significa...
Read more

The Unstoppable Force: Capital’s Demand for Migrant Labour

Internationalism No. 78-79, August-September 2025 Page 16 “Before Giorgia Meloni became Italy’s prime minister, she pledged to cut immigration. Since she has been in government the number of non-EU work visas issued by Italy has increased”. This is how The Economist of April 26th summarises the schizophrenia of their politics; and this is not only true in Italy: “Net migration also surged in post-Brexit Britain”. The needs of the economic system do not coincide with the rhetoric of parliamentarism. And vice versa. Schizophrenia and imbalances in their politics Returning to Italy, the Bank of Italy has pointed out that by 2040, in just fifteen years, there will be a shortage of five million people of working age, which could lead to an estimated 11% contraction in GDP. This is why even Italy’s “sovereignist” government is preparing to widen the net of its Immigration Flow Decree. The latest update, approved on June 30th, provides for the entry of almost ...
Read more

Democratic Defeat in the Urban Vote

Internationalism No. 71, January 2025 Page 2 From the series Elections in the USA A careful analysis of the 2022 mid-term elections revealed the symptoms of a Democratic Party malaise which subsequently fully manifested itself in the latest presidential election, with the heavy loss of support in its traditional strongholds of the metropolitan areas of New York City and Chicago, and the State of California. A defeat foretold Republican votes rose from 51 million in the previous 2018 midterms to 54 million in 2022, a gain of 3 million. The Democrat vote fell from 61 to 51 million, a loss of 10 million. The Republicans gained only three votes for every ten lost by the Democrats, while the other seven became abstentions. In 2022, we analysed the elections in New York City by borough, the governmental districts whose names are well known through movies and TV series. In The Bronx, where the average yearly household income is $35,000, the Democrats lost 52,00...
Read more

‘Two Hands’ and ‘Two Roads’

From the series News from the Silk Road The international tensions which China will face on the seas in the next fifteen years could find a buffer in the expansion of China’s influence on land in Central, Southern and Western Asia. Wang Jisi is the dean of the School of International Studies at the University of Beijing and a major figure of the American party in China. His unexpected foray into ‘geopolitics’ has reignited the old clash between different American currents — a phenomenon we analysed more than twenty years ago. At the time, Robert Manning, the author of The Asian Energy Factor and adviser to the State Department in 1991, viewed Asia’s growing dependence on the Persian Gulf for its energy requirements in the light of geoeconomics and geostrategy and foresaw a possible convergence between the USA and China. From a geoeconomic standpoint, both trade and the funding and development of the infrastructure necessary for Asia’s energy needs were more important than terri...
Read more

Uneven Development, Job Cuts, and the Crisis of Labour Under Global Capitalism

Internationalism No. 73, March 2025 Page 16 Uneven development is a fundamental law of capitalism. We have a macroscopic expression of this in the changing balance of power between States: Atlantic decline and Asian rise are the key dynamics behind the political processes of this era, including wars caused by the crisis in the world order. But behind all this there is a differentiated economic trend, starting from companies and sectors: hence the differentiated conditions for wage earners. And this is the element to keep in mind for an effective defensive struggle. It’s only the beginning The electrical and digital restructuring imposed by global market competition affects various production sectors. The car industry is the most obvious, due to the familiarity of the companies and brands involved. We have already reported on the agreement reached before Christmas at Volkswagen, which can be summarised as a reduction of 35,000 employees by 2030. Die Zeit [De...
Read more

The Defeat in Afghanistan — a Watershed in the Cycle of Atlantic Decline

In crises and wars there are events which leave their mark on history because of how they make a decisive impact on the power contention, or because of how, almost like a chemical precipitate, they suddenly make deep trends that have been at work for some time coalesce. This is the case of the defeat of the United States and NATO in Afghanistan, which is taking the shape of a real watershed in the cycle of Atlantic decline. For the moment, through various comments in the international press, it is possible to consider its consequences on three levels: America’s position as a power and the connection with its internal crisis; the repercussions on Atlantic relations and Europe’s dilemmas regarding its strategic autonomy; and the relationship between the Afghan crisis and power relations in Asia, especially as regards India’s role in the Indo-Pacific strategy. Repercussions in the United States Richard Haass is the president of the CFR, the Council on Foreign Relations; despite having ...
Read more

In the Depth of Our Class

The pandemic of the century is a storm that does not subside; it returns to its rampage after 40 million infections and more than a million official victims, perhaps two million according to estimates on the excess deaths. In the contention between powers, China stands as the winner: it seems to have tamed the virus, and industry and services are up and running; the USA and Europe, on the other hand, are moving towards a new wave of infections that casts yet more shadows on the economic cycle. Political structures and health systems are at the height of tension. In America, the elections have judged Donald Trump’s rash demagogy on the basis of the opposite reasons for containing the pandemic and the intolerance of small and large producers; in Europe the executives are attempting to steer between the surge in infections, increasingly stringent confinement measures and the threats of fiscal jacquerie in the tourism and catering sectors. Almost everywhere, in the Old Continent, governm...
Read more

India’s Weaknesses in the Global Spotlight

Farmers’ protests around New Delhi have been going on for four months now. A controversial intervention by the Supreme Court has suspended the implementation of the new agticultural laws, but has raised questions about the dynamics between the judiciary and the executive, and has failed to unblock the negotiations between government and peasant organisations. The assault by Sikh farmers on the Red Fort during the Republic Day parade as India was displaying its military might to the outside world — the Chinese Global Times maliciously noted — paradoxically widened the protest in the huge state of Uttar Pradesh. The Modi government has been trying to revive India’s image with the 2021 Union Budget: it announced one hundred privatisations and approved the increase to 75% of the limit on direct foreign investment in insurance companies. For The Indian Express ( IEX ) this is a sign of the commitment to push ahead with reforms despite the backlash from rural India. Also for The Economi...
Read more

Europe Follows the USA and China in the Strategic Use of Space

Internationalism No. 33, November 2021 Page 9 From the series The war industry and European defence Next Spring SpaceX will be 20 years old. The company founded by Elon Musk has rapidly achieved a key role in international space activity. The first stage of its Falcon 9 rocket has recently been recovered, reconditioned and reused for the tenth time. SpaceX has already repeated this type of reflight 70 times or so; it allows for substantial savings when compared to the losses incurred in the first stages of a traditional rocket launch. It is for this reason that it is being considered as the standard for the future. According to NASA’s calculations, the average cost of launching a satellite into orbit has fluctuated around the level of $18,500 per kilogram for the whole period between 1970 and 2000. SpaceX has reduced this figure by seven times. Internet constellations In recent missions Falcon 9 rockets have put a total of 60 Starlink satellites ...
Read more

Indo-African Opposition at the WTO

Since March 1 st , the Nigerian economist Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala has been the new director general of the World Trade Organization. Like a coach hired by a team languishing at the bottom of its league — writes Larry Elliott of The Guardian — Okonjo finds herself in the happy position of taking over at the WTO when the only way is up , This historic international institution is unlikely to experience extinction or irrelevance. However, the appointment of Okonjo does not in itself remedy WTO’s deep troubles. An alternative in plurilateralism The negotiating function of the WTO has been lacking for twenty years now. The latest ambitious goal of liberalising trade in goods and services, announced in Doha in November 2001, became bogged down by the impossibility of a general compromise between old powers and large emerging economies. In 2015 Michael Froman, President Barack Obama’s Trade Representative (USTR), officially called for the abandonment of the Doha Round. Froman’s alternative p...
Read more